IBM / Red Hat - Unlock Potential App Modernization
Unlock Your Potential with Application Modernization

Application modernization is a growing area of focus for enterprises. If you’re considering this path to cloud adoption, this guide explores considerations for the best approach – cloud native or legacy migration – and more.

Get the Guide

I was going through my old files and came across my notes on MQ and thought I’d share some reasons to use MQ vs. HTTP:

  • If your consumer processes at a fixed rate (i.e. can’t handle floods to the HTTP server [bursts]) then using MQ provides the flexibility for the service to buffer the other requests vs. bogging it down.
  • Time independent processing and messaging exchange patterns — if the thread is performing a fire-and-forget, then MQ is better suited for that pattern vs. HTTP.
  • Long-lived processes are better suited for MQ as you can send a request and have a seperate thread listening for responses (note WS-Addressing allows HTTP to process in this manner but requires both endpoints to support that capability).
  • Loose coupling where one process can continue to do work even if the other process is not available vs. HTTP having to retry.
  • Request prioritization where more important messages can jump to the front of the queue.
  • XA transactions – MQ is fully XA compliant – HTTP is not.
  • Fault tolerance – MQ messages survive server or network failures – HTTP does not.
  • MQ provides for ‘assured’ delivery of messages once and only once, http does not.
  • MQ provides the ability to do message segmentation and message grouping for large messages – HTTP does not have that ability as it treats each transaction seperately.
  • MQ provides a pub/sub interface where-as HTTP is point-to-point.



Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Arnold Shoon

Solutions Director with 10+ years focused on IBM based large enterprise SOA solutions.

More from this Author

Subscribe to the Weekly Blog Digest:

Sign Up
Follow Us