On April 11, 2016, the Centers for Medicare and Medicare (CMS) announced an initiative called the Comprehensive Primary Care (CPC+). This initiative, which builds on CMS’s previous Comprehensive Primary Care (CPC) initiative, is designed to “improve the quality of care patients receive, improve patients’ health, and spend health care dollars more wisely 1” and similar to the CPC initiative will focus on the five key comprehensive primary care functions: (1) Access and Continuity; (2) Care Management; (3) Comprehensiveness and Coordination; (4) Patient and Caregiver Engagement; and (5) Planned Care and Population Health.
CMS describes CPC+ as “a national advanced primary care medical home model that aims to strengthen primary care through a regionally-based multi-payer payment reform and care delivery transformation. CPC+ will include two primary care practice tracks with incrementally advanced care delivery requirements and payment options to meet the diverse needs of primary care practices in the United States (U.S.). The multi-payer payment redesign will give practices greater financial resources and flexibility to make appropriate investments to improve the quality and efficiency of care, and reduce unnecessary health care utilization. CPC+ will provide practices with a robust learning system, as well as actionable patient-level cost and utilization data feedback, to guide their decision making 1.”
According to VMG Health, CPC+ is expected to involve up to 5,000 practices and 20,000 physicians in 20 regions, amounting to over 25 million patients, throughout its five-year plan starting January 2017 and providers can participate in CPC+ under two tracks, which will both provide a monthly care management fee and upfront performance-based incentive payments, the latter of which is subject to return at year end if certain quality and utilization standards are not met 2. Key difference between the two tracks are as follows:
The Upside
The upside to CPC+ is the goal to shift from the traditional reactive, episodic-driven, fee-for-service model to a more proactive, comprehensive, value-based care delivery model has good intentions. To further support this methodology, CPC+ has identified five key components it’s aiming to achieve, at minimum 3:
In order to hit the mark on these types of services, healthcare organizations are without a doubt going to have to heavily foster an IT dependent, data centric, collaborative approach amounts all the players. The support for is evident by CMS requesting vendors, within Track 2, to sign a Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) with CMS that outlines their commitment to supporting practices enhancement of health IT capabilities. Increasing the holistic model through information sharing is key to delivering the proactive, information driven, high-value care the initiative looks to accomplish.
In addition, according to analysis conducted by Paul Ginsburg, Margaret Darling, and Kavita Patel of the Brookings Institute, “The combination of larger per beneficiary monthly payments and lower payments for services is the most important part of the initiative. By blending capitation (monthly payments not tied to service volume) and FFS (fee-for-service), this approach might achieve the best of both worlds4.” The analysis also highlights the impact of increasing payments to access to care through maintaining primary care physicians, “An advantage of any program that increases payments to primary care practices is that it can partially compensate for a flaw in the relative value scale behind the Medicare physician fee schedule. This flaw leads to underpayment for primary care services. Higher payments for primary care practices through the CPC+ can help slow the degree to which physicians are leaving primary care until more fundamental fixes are made to the fee schedule.4”
The Potential Downside
As with most things in this world, with the good could come the potential bad. Though the CPC+ program certainly is in the right mind set to drive quality care via a more comprehensive delivery model, the Brookings Institute analysis notes two potential missed opportunities 4:
The critical role primary care plays in reducing overall healthcare cost is well accepted and little to no argument should be made against initiatives that improve various aspects of its delivery whether clinical, operational and/or financial. What seems to be up for debate is, which of countless initiative does an organization/practice participate? Given that there seems to be overlapping and perhaps contradictory initiatives in place, it may be time to take a good hard look at the present state of healthcare and reassess, prioritize and, if needed, decommission those initiatives that are no longer applicable or can be replaces by one more suitable based on a more innovative path to drive optimal quality of care while reducing overall spend on healthcare.
What do you think? Do you think CPC+ will drive changes in primary care practices?
Resources for this blog post:
Medicare is basing hospital reimbursements on performance measures. Patient satisfaction determines 30% of the incentive payments, and improved clinical outcomes decide 70 percent (source). So, it is no surprise that the term “patient experience” is rolling off people’s tongues very matter-of-fact like.
With the focus primarily on the hospital or inpatient setting, it’s easy to forget about the ambulatory or outpatient setting when it comes to patient experience. However, as the country continues to shift its efforts to preventing medical problems rather than simply fixing them, the spotlight is moving to the outpatient setting. Therefore, it is equally, if not more important for those in the medical practices to take the necessary steps to assure their patients’ experiences are top notch in this new care delivery model.
Positive Outcomes and Opportunities
The benefits to improving patient experience are plentiful, regardless of the care setting. However, the Language of Caring has done a great job highlighting and explaining specific areas within the outpatient setting where increasing quality patient experience can bring about positive contributions and opportunities. Here are the exact details they provide:
As the U.S strives to change patient experience from a fad to a priority in how we deliver care, outpatient medical practices need to understand the positive impact improvement can make, not only to their business operations, but more importantly to the outcome of patient care.
What other benefits do you see by improving your patient’s experience?
]]>
Once upon a time last year, in a town not too far from you, there was a big hospital where a bright, young physician was providing care to a sick, old patient. Okay, let me save you some time. This fairytale, unlike those you are used to, doesn’t end simply by having Prince Charming (the physician) swoop in and save the beautiful, damsel in distress (patient). This fairytale has a bit of twist that changes the standard storyline. This twist is referred to as Patient Engagement.
Changing of the Patient-Provider Fairytale
The concept of patient engagement has changed the way providers tell their patient stories. It is no longer, once upon a time, a patient was sick, the physician cured him/her, the end.
The fairytale now reads more like this…
Patient engagement is not a new concept, just one that has been brought to the forefront as part of the healthcare industry’s increased efforts around coordinated care. So much so, that this year at the Health Information Management System Society’s (HIMSS) Annual Conference in Orlando, FL., there are over 20 educational sessions on the topic. Given the importance of patient engagement, I can assure you there will be longer lines to get into these sessions than there will be to get into the castle of the ultimate fairytale princess, Cinderella, at Disney World down the street.
Patient engagement allows patients and their families to be active participants in their care through increased collaboration and communication with their care teams. It moves away from the “I say, you do” approach and allows patients and providers to make informed decisions as they advance toward agreed upon goals surrounding care. As a justifiable way to increase quality of care and reduce healthcare costs, providers are being financially incentivized, through things like Meaningful Use Stage 2, to increase their efforts surrounding patient engagement in hopes that they realize the many benefits it can bring.
The Happily Ever After
To promote stronger engagement, the Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality (AHRQ) developed the Guide to Patient and Family Engagement in Hospital Quality and Safety, a tested, evidence-based resource to help hospitals work as partners with patients and families to improve quality and safety1. In this guide, AHRQ has identified and explained seven key areas where improving patient engagement can greatly benefit your organization2:
With its many benefits, clinically and financially, patient engagement is encouraging a new kind of storytelling. It is allowing providers to take the basic patient-provider fairytale and turn it into a memorable one, one that people want to keep reading because the ending is so good. You know, the “and they lived happily ever after” kind.
Are you writing memorable patient stories through patient engagement?
Come see us at HIMSS 2014 – Booth # 2035.
Resources for this blog post:
]]>
What’s transforming the ways in which healthcare is provided?
Susan DeVore, CEO of our partner and client Premier healthcare alliance, wrote a post yesterday fro HealthAffairs.gov titled, “The Changing Health Care World: Trends To Watch In 2014.” In the article, she introduces the new trends she expects to see in healthcare this year. We are also seeing each of these trends impact conversations about investments our clients need to make this year and next year.
I have summarized the trends below.
1. Investments in Chronic Care –
2. New Job Roles in Healthcare
3. Home Health Care
4. Employer Attention on Health
5. Private exchanges become more popular
6. Further movement toward Value-Based Purchasing
7. Data will begin to talk as walls fall down
8. New and more creative partnerships in healthcare
Exciting stuff!
]]>
I just finished watching a quick slideshow on the Health Data Management website, “Enterprise Analytics: Moving on Up” and as luck would have it, I also watched several sessions of the live Webcast from the Healthcare Innovation Day Conference 2014 in Washington, DC, sponsored by West Health Institute and the Office of the National Coordinator for Health Information Technology (ONC).
While I was watching these, I was intrigued by the thought of how Accountable Care Organizations (ACO) can leverage existing solutions, combined with point solutions, to accomplish their reporting, analytics and beyond, and use interoperability wisely. One of the key learning points for me from these sessions was this: “Reframe the problem”….advice from Malcolm Gladwell’s keynote address.
How do we “reframe the problem” when it comes to ACO reporting and analytics? There are defined metrics that are required for these organizations, so how can we leverage existing systems to create these reports and analytics? Do we “build vs. buy”? Depending upon the organizational size, legacy systems and IT support, the decision can be difficult. What is good for one system may not work in another. So where do we start?
A strategic evaluation of current state and desired future state with the development of a road map may be a logical first step. Data Governance also needs to happen early on in the process to allow an organization to create data standards that will drive reporting and analytics. Once these steps have occurred, an organization can feel confident that they can make an informed decision to “build or buy.”
If you choose to build, there are excellent offerings for Enterprise Data Warehouse (EDW), Enterprise Master Patient Index (EMPI), and reporting and analytics solutions from IBM, Microsoft and Oracle.
The “buy” decision can be even tougher because there are numerous point solutions available which can be layered onto existing legacy systems to extract data for reporting and analytics. Many times these solutions have very defined purposes, which may be exactly what you need to fill a gap in your reporting structure at a lower cost than building it. There are solutions which focus primarily on ACO’s, Care Coordination or Population Health. If needed, there are also point solutions which provide excellent reporting capabilities with familiar outputs such as PowerView and PowerPivot, Cognos or Business Objects.
So “reframe the problem” by evaluating what works best for your organization.
“Take all these extraordinary tools we have out there, and have them work together and who knows what extraordinary changes that can bring about?” Gladwell concluded in his speech. “You are on to something very crucial here, and I wish you all the best.”
Go to HIMSS and start looking. Perficient would be happy to help! Stop by Booth 2035 to see us.
]]>The patient centered medical home (PCMH) emphasizes care coordination and communication between various healthcare delivery systems. This coordinated care system can lead to better quality healthcare delivery as well as a better patient experience – but in order to achieve these benefits, providers must be able to see and interpret data from across the many entities the patient interacts with.
Leveraging clinical data from EMRs, HIEs and patient devices allows organizations to:
Join us October 29th for the webinar “Make the Most of Your ACO with Healthcare Analytics.” You will learn how Oracle Enterprise Health Analytics (EHA), coupled with Oracle Business Intelligence and Oracle WebCenter, fulfills the ACO mandate for a patient centered medical home.
Click here to register for the webinar.
]]>Oracle OpenWorld 2013 turned out to be one of my best experiences with a trade-show ever! I made new contacts, I learned about product strategy and I learned about awesome customer stories related to innovative healthcare solutions.
Perficient’s Lesli Adams @lesliadams provided innovative solution overviews highlighting healthcare business intelligence solutions #OBIEE for Patient Centered Medical Home and Accountable Care analytics with Dr. Marcie Stoshak-Chavez @DrMarcieSC, as well as, a session presentation highlighting use cases for #BigData in Healthcare. Lesli also provided great insight to information discovery using both structured and unstructured data at the #BigData demo grounds with Oracle’s Jim McDowell .
I also attended several sessions about how provider organizations are leveraging Hyperion Profitability & Cost Management to achieve profit and loss transparency via activity based costing. These leading edge organizations are working with both hospitals and physicians to build models that truly capture service line and encounter level profitability and cost.
I made many new contacts in the Oracle CX space while also beefing up my knowledge about Oracle SOA and the Oracle HC SOA Adapter solution with Perficient’s Eric Roch @eroch2 about automating migrations from legacy HL7 platforms to Fusion Middleware. I’m looking forward to more thought leadership about both these subjects in the coming months from Perficient.
These solutions are innovating and these organizations are movers and shakers and I couldn’t be more excited about working with Oracle Healthcare solutions in the coming year!
Follow me on Twitter @teriemc
]]>The healthcare IT field is rapidly developing and changing. Emerging technology and updated regulations put pressure on healthcare providers and health plans to stay ahead of the curve. Perficient creates a monthly list that explores some of the current topics and issues in health IT. This list examines the most talked about issues and technologies that are currently affecting the industry.
An ACO is a group of healthcare providers that partner under a payment and delivery reform model that become collectively accountable for the full continuum of care for a population of patients. This reform model ultimately ties reimbursement to quality metrics and reductions in the total cost of care for the patient population. First year results for ACOs were recently released, with very mixed success and several hospitals dropping out of the program.
With the progression of patient engagement, consumers are looking to become involved in their own care and health. The quantified self movement helps patients track their health, physical activity, food consumption, heart rate, and more. From mobile apps to worn digital sensors like the FitBit to implanted devices, patients keep track of their own health data – which eventually may be used to create a more personalized experience.
It is a common opinion that our healthcare system does not provide good value for the care received. Incentives for hospitals are not properly matched with delivering the best possible care at an affordable rate. In response, healthcare payment reform models have been created. Bundled payments reimburse healthcare providers based on the expected cost of a group of services delivered, instead of payment for each treatment provided. Hospital value based purchasing tie reimbursement to the quality of care delivered based on clinical results and patient satisfaction.
The Patient Protection and the Affordable Care Act, or Obamacare, was introduced in 2010 as a national healthcare plan to reform the American healthcare system. Starting in October 2013, over 48 million uninsured Americans will be eligible for enrollment in subsidized plans through state-run health insurance exchanges, with annually increasing fines for those who go uncovered. A recent delay in the requirement that employers with over 50 employees provide health insurance or face a penalty has caused a stir, as some interpret this as the government acknowledging the heavy strain of Obamacare.
PHM aims to improve the overall health of high- and low risk patients by addressing personal health behaviors. PHM places an emphasis on primary care to provide preventative, acute and chronic illness care, which is coupled with efforts to educate patients and encourage behavior and lifestyle changes.
]]>
The healthcare IT field is rapidly developing and changing. Emerging technology and updated regulations put pressure on healthcare providers and health plans to stay ahead of the curve. Perficient creates a monthly list that explores some of the current topics and issues in health IT. This list examines the most talked about issues and technologies that are currently affecting the industry.
An ACO is a group of healthcare providers that partner under a payment and delivery reform model that become collectively accountable for the full continuum of care for a population of patients. This reform model ultimately ties reimbursement to quality metrics and reductions in the total cost of care for the patient population. Patient Centered Medical Homes (PCMH) focus on improving the quality of care delivered by creating a health care environment that facilitates communication between the patient and their physician, allowing patients to receive and understand the care they need when they need it.
The healthcare industry is experiencing revolutionary changes stemming from the rapidly shifting role of the patient within the continuum of care. This is resulting in high demand for easier access to healthcare professionals, access to online medical information, and alternatives to traditional care. Telehealth allows for the transmission of medical images, video, audio and information related to diagnosis and treatment can be stored and sent from the provider’s computer or mobile device via secure data exchanges. Remote Patient Monitoring allows patient’s health data to be sent electronically to a provider who then can analyze it and respond with appropriate recommendations.
Exchanges are organizations that will encourage a more organized and competitive market for buying health insurance. They offer different health plan options; certifying plans that participate and providing information to help consumers better understand their options. These exchanges will open in October 2013 with a required start date by 2014, and will assist individuals and small businesses in comparing and purchasing health insurance coverage.
Starting in October 2014, the U.S. healthcare system will begin mandating the use of ICD-10 codes to replace the ICD-9 coding system. The updated ICD-10 codes will be more specific and allow for more precise billing and address advances in medical knowledge and technology. While ICD-10 implementation can be challenging and places new demands on the provider community, it also opens up the opportunity for deeper data, which can be a tool to improve care and lower costs.
Social networking and collaboration tools provide one-to-one streams of interactive communication which enable patients to seek out information about diseases and treatment options. Social tools can also be used to facilitate collaboration within the enterprise between clinicians, researchers, and partners. Social media has been used effectively for patients with cancer, diabetes, congestive heart failure, asthma, obesity etc. to help patients manage chronic disease and prevent readmission.
]]>I was recently talking with one of my colleagues about a strange situation that happened to her when her local hospital and healthcare provider merged with a larger healthcare system. As a result of the merger, she no longer had a local healthcare provider in her town that took her insurance plan. In essence, she was a victim of healthcare merger mania and had to find a new healthcare insurance plan for coverage. Healthcare organization mergers are part of a broad national trend that is driven by accountable care and the tremendous pressure to cut costs, improve productivity and improve outcomes.
As a result of this merger trend, medical care is being concentrated in fewer institutions, and concern about the impact on higher prices is increasing. A hospital merger boom in the 1990s increased patient costs by 5 to 40 percent in areas where only a few hospitals dominate, according to the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation. Large healthcare organizations with multiple hospitals tend to charge higher prices in communities where they outnumber their rivals, says health economist James C. Robinson of the University of California, Berkeley. This information contradicts the usual arguments for accountable care that merging or affiliating with generate greater efficiencies, higher quality of care and increased savings. More than 100 hospital merger deals took place in 2012, double the number of only three years earlier. Here is the scary statistic: Of the 5,724 hospitals in the United States, about 1,000 will have new owners in the next seven years or so, according to Gary Ahlquist, a senior partner with the consulting firm Booz & Company.
In a sense, the days of the community hospital as a stand-alone operation are coming to an end like the family farm was pushed out by corporate farming. With the recession and higher deductibles causing people to put off medical treatments, the hospital is faced with empty beds and a pressing need to consolidate to lower costs. As patients seek lower costs, many of them opt for out-patient surgery or procedures conducted in the doctor’s office versus the hospital. One irony is that hospitals that hire physicians or acquire physician practices then see an increase in patients as they come to see their doctors.
The Affordable Care Act will flood millions of new patients into the health care system with a goal of promoting competition and lowering the cost of care. To lower costs, the law reduces the rate of growth in Medicare payments to hospitals. In addition, the law provides incentives for hospitals to form Accountable Care Organizations. Instead of separate fees for each procedure, ACOs will receive a lump sum payment, called a bundled payment, to care for patients. The bundled payment is designed to make hospitals work harder to provide good care, control costs and keep patients healthy. The ACO concept is encouraging these mergers or consolidations rather than driving more competition. As a result, less competition will drive up costs for patients, especially in a regional area.
A system of multiple hospitals formed as an ACO creates a collective bargaining unit that is better positioned to bargain with health insurance companies. As a result, the ACO can demand higher prices for its services and, potentially, remove healthcare access for patients that have healthcare plans that won’t meet these new demands. The statistics from James C. Robinson, the health economist from Berkeley, show that prices for six major cardiac and orthopedic surgery procedures, in hospitals in eight states, were 13 to 25 percent more than in areas where there was less competition. Ultimately, the patient pays the higher prices in insurance premiums, deductibles, co-payments and hospital bills when the ACOs win out over the health insurance companies.
Where is the oversight on these hospital mergers and the examination of the loss of real competition in a regional area? The Federal Trade Commission, the Justice Department and some states require oversight of mergers and a few hospitals mergers have been blocked. More care must be taken by these regulatory bodies to avoid regional mini-monopolies that can be created by ACOs and the subsequent loss of healthcare access experienced by people with the “wrong” health insurance company. In addition, a broader scrutiny beyond Medicare and Medicaid needs to be instituted around the impact of ACOs on the medical costs to patients. It is fair to say that hospitals and physician practices are in a tough squeeze with more patients and cost reduction pressures, but ACOs need more focus on the downstream impacts of driving up costs for their patients or potentially removing their access to local healthcare.
Are ACOs causing unintentional consequences on costs for patients? What’s your opinion?
]]>The healthcare IT field is rapidly developing and changing. Emerging technology and updated regulations put pressure on healthcare providers and health plans to stay ahead of the curve. Perficient creates a monthly list that explores some of the current topics and issues in health IT. This list examines the most talked about issues and technologies that are currently affecting the industry.
The term “patient engagement” is on the tip of the healthcare industry’s tongue these days. We can only end the long-running trend of low patient engagement, along with the dangerously high cost of care, by shifting to true patient engagement that holds the patient experience, and the power of the resulting data, at forefront of healthcare business strategy. The healthcare industry is shifting emphasis to the patient, caused not only by government mandates but also by a shift in consumer expectations inspired by other industries that have permeated healthcare.
It is a common opinion that our healthcare system does not provide good value for the care received. Incentives for hospitals are not properly matched with delivering the best possible care at an affordable rate. In response, healthcare payment reform models have been created. Bundled payments reimburse healthcare providers based on the expected cost of a group of services delivered, instead of payment for each treatment provided. Hospital value based purchasing tie reimbursement to the quality of care delivered based on clinical results and patient satisfaction.
The Patient Protection and the Affordable Care Act, or Obamacare, was introduced in 2010 as a national healthcare plan to reform the American healthcare system. Starting in October 2013, over 48 million uninsured Americans will be eligible for enrollment in subsidized plans through state-run health insurance exchanges, with annually increasing fines for those who go uncovered. Adding millions of consumers to the health care system will increase consumption dramatically and put a strain on providers.
An ACO is a group of healthcare providers that partner under a payment and delivery reform model that become collectively accountable for the full continuum of care for a population of patients. This reform model ultimately ties reimbursement to quality metrics and reductions in the total cost of care for the patient population. PHM aims to improve the overall health of high- and low risk patients by addressing personal health behaviors. PHM places an emphasis on primary care to provide preventative, acute and chronic illness care, which is coupled with efforts to educate patients and encourage behavior and lifestyle changes.
The healthcare industry generates massive volumes of data, which often isn’t leveraged to its full potential. In an industry where competitive pressures and regulatory demands are intense, information is a critical business asset, and healthcare organizations can’t afford to stay behind. Analysis of Big Data can help proactively monitor the health of the community population and respond to conditions such as potential illness outbreaks.
]]>Almost everyone can relate to being a patient but not everyone can relate to the challenges of coordinated care management. I’m here at the Patient Experience Summit at the Cleveland Clinic learning how providers will need to shift their culture and their resources to engage patients to be involved in their own care as well as working with the community for case management.
In addition to this culture shift, providers need to think strategically about technology to innovate in this space. I saw a great presentation that explains how many progressive organizations are shifting to a 360 view of the patient viewing using service automation technologies like those that have been innovating within other industries for years. These organizations are cultivating patient experience across many domains… not just their health and wellness. For example, how many former patients put their names on new buildings?
Perficient is uniquely positioned to provide both strategic consulting and technology innovation to help meet these challenges through our partnership with Oracle and experience implementing social collaborative technologies via Oracle platforms such as WebCenter Suite, RightNow, and other CX solutions.
Stop by booth #27 to see our portal demo that showcases engaged patients using social media technology. The demo provides examples of physician to physician collaboration, branding, service catalog, way finding and mobile health.
]]>